When you have sensitive eyes and you wear contact lenses, finding a mild non-smudge mascara is a challenge. One of the problems I had to manage in the past years was that my eyes got more and more sensitive and they did not suffer plenty of cosmetic or makeup products. I actually had given up using mascara completely. Even if I tried a few of the major brands, my eyes still got watery, red, and itchy in the middle of the day.

One of my friends spoke about organic mascara at some point. She described it to be mild, smudge-proof, and mild for sensitive eyes and contact lenses wearers. Of course, I wanted to know more. She recommended me the Mia Adora organic mascara as being one of the best drugstore mascara options on the market.

​While I do not want to abuse my already sensitive eyes with more cosmetic products, I decided to try this mascara. I was incredibly pleased with the results. I have been using it for three months now, on a daily basis, I can say it is exactly what I have been looking for. Before I overwhelm you with my enthusiasm, however, I want to share some of the things you need to consider before buying the product.

​Things to Consider before Buying the Mia Adora Organic Mascara

I am not a stranger to using makeup, although I limited the amount of products I use on and around my eyes. Eyeliners, mascaras, and makeup sometimes make my eyes sting, itch, cry, and feel heavy. I do not know it is a form of allergy or too much eye sensitivity, but the problems are real and hard to deal with. I have to admit I have never used organic mascara until I got my hands on the Mia Adora one, and I can say I was very pleased with the results.

I need to look great every day at the office and I also need to look great after the office hours when I have to attend all sorts of social gatherings. This is what a PR does and nobody likes a PR with runny mascara or teary eyes. The Mia Adora worked great for me – but these are the issues you need to think about before buying it:

  • Hold: The mascara will hold its grounds an entire day if you do not rub your eyes, run in the park or go dancing in the rain. It is not waterproof and it is smudge-proof in decent limitations.
  • Number of coatings: The manufacturer says 1-3 coatings. I only needed two, but you can use the third one as well if you want more pigmentation. My lashes did not feel heavy or clumpy in two coatings.     
  • Pigmentation: This mascara offers you the blackest black. If you want to achieve such a look, then go for it!
  • Removal: Remember that this is now waterproof, so splashing your eyes with some water during office hours may lead to unpleasant results. As makeup remover is concerned, you will be able to clean the mascara with your regular makeup remover or a warm water cotton pad with no problems.

Who Should Buy This Drugstore Mascara

Women who have sensitive eyes, wear contacts, want a mild and strongly pigmented mascara that holds for hours.

Best Organic Mascara - Black Natural Mascara Ingredients for Longer Lashes - Hypoallergenic...
  • NO SMEAR OR SMUDGE - Smudge proof and Budge Proof. Non Toxic ingredients for the...
  • GUILT FREE, FULL LASHES - Make your lashes POP, with this Natural and Organic...
  • NO CLUMPING, FLAKING AND SMUDGE PROOF - Professional Mascara that add Length and...

Who Should Not Buy This Drugstore Mascara

 Women who want waterproof mascara.

Mia Adora Organic Mascara

​This Mia Adora organic mascara comes with a nice wand that is easy to hold and use. The mascara itself is also easy to put on. The pigmentation is great and you will probably need only two coatings. It does not feel heavy or thick on the lashes. In addition, the formula comes with organic chamomile, beeswax & organic carnauba wax, organic sunflower oil, added vitamin E, organic rosemary leaf extract, organic lavender flower and even more natural ingredients and sub-products. What I want to say is that the formula is great to nourish and protect your lashes, not just make them blacker. If your eyes’ sensitivity is your first priority, then this mascara will answer plenty of your problems. It also comes with a nice volumizing effect. On the other hand, it also comes with its fair share of drawbacks. Next, I will summarize the pros and the cons of this product.


  • Organic and containing natural ingredients
  • Great lash cover and pigmentation
  • Great hold


  • Not waterproof
  • Does not have significant length and volume effect
  • Hard to find on the market

Mia Adora Organic Mascara Features and Benefits​ 

I started using mascara in my teenage years. Everything seemed fine, but then my eye problems began to show, as I was getting older and older: allergies, sensitivity to environmental factors, face skin sensitivity, and so on. Then, in college, I learned I needed to wear glasses. I rejected the proposal and switched to contacts instead. Since then, using eyeliners, mascaras, eyelid makeup and other cosmetic products turned into a daily challenge.

When you are young, you can get away with not using more than a sweet lip-gloss. When you have a public face people associate with a big brand name, things do not get easier. For this reason, I started using eye makeup again, fully aware that it would take its toll. Now that my friend recommended me the Mia Adora organic mascara, I am happy to report my view on cosmetics changed drastically. It is not like I do not afford a label cosmetic product. However, now that I entered the small but loyal club of best drugstore mascara lovers, I do not want to leave it.

Back to my Mia Adora experience, allow me to tell you what I loved best about it.

  • Excellent for sensitive eyes. If your eyes itch and sting simply because you go outside the house, you know what I am talking about: no makeup is good enough. However, I found that this mascara did the job great and did not have any unpleasant side effect during the day.
  • Excellent for contact lenses. Women with glasses and contact lenses dread mascara for all the right reasons. However, this one worked perfectly in tandem with my contacts. Refrain from rubbing your eyes and you will be just fine.
  • The wand is easy to use, ergonomic, and comfortable. Of course, you need to master your mascara application skills, but I think this one will also please the beginner young ladies.    
  • The formula comes with great benefits for your lashes and skin. Besides the fact that it is organic and natural, this mascara contains ingredients that nourish and protect your lashes, boost their looks and health. I personally enjoyed the added vitamin E. I also enjoyed the fact that it contained organic coconut oil that helps stimulate natural eyelash growth.
  • The formula is also hypoallergenic and non-toxic. This means you can use the mascara even if you have some allergies. The formula does not contain artificial dyes.
  • The mascara is somewhat water resistant, although it is not waterproof.
  • The mascara is cruelty free. For me, this was a dealmaker, because I do not condone animal testing in the cosmetic industry.
  • The mascara is made in the USA, another point won by the product. Let us face it: if you get a good product and support a local entrepreneur in the same time, why wouldn’t you buy that product?

[scrapeazon asin=”B0748JTYQM” width=“600” height=“600” border=”false”]

​Alternatives to the Mia Adora Organic Mascara

Browsing the Internet for reviews, I found more products that spiked my interest. I want to show you three of them so that you can pick your favorite one and make it work the best for you!

This mascara also comes with raving reviews and a great formula for you to consider if you want to use natural ingredients.

Who Should Use this Mascara

Women with allergies, sensitive eyes, who also want vegan, gluten-free, cruelty free mascara.

Endlessly Beautiful Mascara vs. Mia Adora Mascara Comparison

  • Both are organic and containing natural ingredients;
  • Both share the same price;
  • Endlessly Beautiful is 100% natural, 85% organic vegan and gluten free formula;
  • Endlessly Beautiful adds more volume and length to eyelashes evenly and smoothly;
  • Endlessly Beautiful is also water resistant, but not waterproof.

If you want an alternative to the Mia Adora mascara, check out the Endlessly Beautiful Organic Mascara to make the best choice for you!

The Naturally Rooted Organic Mascara is also a crowd pleaser. You can read some reviews and make your own opinion about it. I think it is a very interesting alternative to Mia Adora.

Who Should Use this Mascara

Women who want paraben free, dye free, gluten free, and dye free, making it the great mascara for sensitive eyes.

Naturally Rooted Mascara vs. Mia Adora Mascara Comparison

  • Both are organic;
  • Naturally Rooted is 100% natural, 85% organic and it is cruelty free;
  • Naturally Rooted is cheaper;
  • Naturally Rooted is even smoother than Mia Adora;
  • Naturally Rooted is also water resistant but not waterproof.

If you want an alternative to the Mia Adora mascara, check out the Naturally Rooted Organic Mascara! It may be the answer to your mascara searches!

This is another great entry on the best drugstore mascara products area and seems to cover all issues, including highest quality non-toxic, natural and safe ingredients.

Who Should Use this Mascara

Women who want lavish eyelash growth and volumizing, which lasts all day/night, is waterproof and smudge proof.

Hairgenics Lavish Lash HD vs. Mia Adora Mascara Comparison

  • Hairgenics is not organic;
  • Hairgenics is hypoallergenic, non-irritating, clinically tested, allergy tested and dermatologist tested;
  • Hairgenics helps enhance the length, volume and thickness of your lashes;
  • Both come with the same price;
  • Hairgenics is manufactured in FDA certified labs.

If you feel you want to try a more traditional mascara, the Hairgenics mascara may be the one you were looking for!

Best Organic Mascara - Black Natural Mascara Ingredients for Longer Lashes - Hypoallergenic...
  • NO SMEAR OR SMUDGE - Smudge proof and Budge Proof. Non Toxic ingredients for the...
  • GUILT FREE, FULL LASHES - Make your lashes POP, with this Natural and Organic...
  • NO CLUMPING, FLAKING AND SMUDGE PROOF - Professional Mascara that add Length and...


Smudge-proof, water-resistant, healthy lashes, great for sensitive eyes, good pigment and good hold – these were the main reasons I chose this product. I think it will work great for young and adult women alike. If you are also in favor of cruelty free and chemical free products, this is a good product to begin with.

If you wear contacts and you have sensitive eyes, then you should try this mascara. It goes on well on the lashes; it does not smudge under normal circumstances even if it is not waterproof. On the other hand, there are other alternatives you can consider – some are organic and some are not. I enjoyed the natural and organic formula of this mascara and I found that it made my lashes stronger and well defined.

If you are a beginner in using mascara, this product may be a good way to start. Young women should be careful about what they use, especially in their eyes areas. Being organic, this mascara will not affect you in any negative way. Moreover, it has a good hold, the wand is excellent, and the pigmentation is just great. I would not recommend the product if you want to achieve surreal long sexy lashes. There are other products for that. However, I do recommend this for daily wear when all you need to worry about is the job. Since it works well with glasses and contact lenses, you should be just fine. It also goes great with your after-hours activities, just be reminded it is not waterproof.

A small (but not insurmountable) problem is that you may not always find it in online stores. However, the manufacturer’s website is a great place to begin your search. The product is affordable and you will find it brings great value for your money.

In conclusion, if you want a great product with visible great results, try the Mia Adora organic mascara! You will not regret you bought it! Who knows, this may also open your path towards trying more organic cosmetic products.

Last update on 2022-08-30 at 12:54 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API