Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara Review

Maybelline define a lash mascara review

It is probably obvious for all women out there why Maybelline gets on any list of best drugstore mascara products. With a strong reputation and excellent products, Maybelline is a big name when it comes to mascaras. As a woman in their twenties, I love to try to experiment with different mascaras for different occasions, and Maybelline was on my short list.

I have rather short lashes and I always look for a pitch-black tint, so the Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara seemed to be what I was looking for. The price is very convincing, together with the Maybelline name, so I bought this mascara wholeheartedly. I also checked out the reviews on the product and even if they were not 5-stars feedback, I considered that the product was good enough for me to test it.

Before I go to the actual review, I have to say that I wear contact lenses, so I needed a mascara to work well with them. The product’s label says this mascara is ophthalmologist-tested and contact lens safe – two features that convinced me even more to buy the product.

​I used the mascara for about a month, on an everyday basis. I go to college almost daily and I also have a part-time job in between classes. It is safe to think I go out early in the morning and come back late at night most days and weekends. In other words, you need a dash of mascara to be mild with your eyes and stay on as long as it is possible. Now let me share with you my experience with this particular product

​Things to Consider before Buying the Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara

Young women who juggle college and a job know they need resistant and reliable makeup to last them all day long. While I do like to use several mascaras, eyeliners, and other cosmetic products depending on the occasion, I also like to rely on my makeup to allow me to look nice and not the IT clown.

The product did not disappoint in the pigmentation department, nor in the contact-lenses safe one. The wand is just amazing – probably the best thing about it – but I had to pay attention to my look now and then to make sure I removed the flakes and clumps. Otherwise, this is a product worth trying if you do not mind the fact that it will not last 12 hours straight.

Now let me tell you a few things about this mascara so you can understand things better:

  • Possible side effects: Since I have contact lenses, I wanted the best of both worlds: reputable brand mascara that is good for my eyes. This mascara was very gentle with my eyes and did not clash against my contacts. However, if you experience discomfort symptoms, you should immediately stop using it.     

  • Hold: I have mascaras that will hold all day long without a problem. They are more expensive than this one, even if they do not belong to large brands such as Maybelline. This mascara will start to flake and clump after a few hours, so you need to clean things up and reapply it. It may not happen to you as well, but it did happen to me and I think it is only fair to let you know.  

  • Efficiency: The deep dark black tint is a reality. It works amazing with eyeliners and other cosmetics if you want to achieve amazing cat and smoky eyes. The pigmentation is indeed great and it rises to the expectations brought by the Maybelline name.  

  • Number of coatings: I would not recommend more than two coatings. I am afraid that more than two coatings will speed up the clumping and flaking process.

  • Pigmentation: This mascara offers you a great black tint. This is one of the things I absolutely loved about it.

  • Removal: The mascara is not waterproof – but there is a waterproof version if you are interested. It is removable with makeup remover or a cotton pad soaked in warm water.    

  • Expiration date: Never use a product that went past its expiration date. Also, if the mascara gets an odd smell, color, or texture, stop using it altogether.

  • Wand and brush: The wand and brush are exquisite. As I said, they are probably the best thing about the product in general. The product glides on smoothly on your lashes. The branded Shaped-To-The-Lash Brush elongates and accentuates lashes.

Who Should Buy This Drugstore Mascara

If you want your lashes to get darker and longer, you can try this product. It works well with contact lenses. It has a nice brush and if you want a half day of gorgeous looks, you can try it.

Maybelline Define-A-Lash Lengthening Washable Mascara, Very Black. For Washable Definition and Shape...
  • Use Maybelline Define-A-Lash Lengthening Washable Mascara, Very Black, for...
  • Define-A-Lash Lengthening Washable Mascara gives definition and shape for...
  • To safeguard purity, reserve this mascara for your personal use. Treat the...

Who Should Not Buy This Drugstore Mascara

 Women who want longer-holding mascaras that do not clump.

​Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara

​This Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara comes with a deep black pigmentation and an elongation effect I think you will appreciate a lot. While it works well helping you achieve nice seductive eyes, it will clump eventually. If you want the waterproof version, you can easily buy it online. The price is excellent even if it will only last half a day. But let me summarize the pros and cons of this product how I saw them after one month of use.


  • Very affordable
  • Excellent black tint and elongation effect
  • Good for contact lenses wearers


  • It clumps fast and needs readjusting
  • It smudges after 6-7 hours
  • You will get better volume and length with other similar products

​Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara Features and Benefits

I started using this mascara and I found it to be above average in terms of pigmentation, coverage, and lash length effect. However, I found the formula to be average when it comes to smudging, clumping, and hold. Nevertheless, I found this product to have plenty of features and benefits and I want to share them with you now.

  • Good for sensitive eyes. I do not have sensitive eyes but I think the formula is mild enough. The label says the product is ophthalmological tested and even if it is not an organic product, I think you will not encounter problems when using it on a daily basis.

  • Good for contact lenses wearers. Some mascaras clash against glasses or contact lenses. I chose this product as its description said it was safe for contacts. In my opinion, it was.
  • It dries fast. The mascara glides on smoothly, but after 6 or 7 hours, it tends to clump and flake. It should not be a problem, unless you do not have the times and means to readjust your makeup during the day.      

  • The formula makes your lashes look voluminous and long. I chose this product for everyday casual wear. I have other mascaras for formal wear that hold on more and have a glossy feline effect.

  • It is easy to apply. One of the best things about this product is its brush. It has a special shape that will help you get full coverage. Even if you are a beginner in using mascara (I am thinking about teenage girls here), you should not have any issues with it. The brush also leads to a curving effect all women love about their lashes.  

  • The mascara is easily removable. Your regular makeup remover will help you wash off the mascara easily. The product is washable with warm water.  

  • It holds well for a few hours. Many reported the clumpy effect of the product after a few hours, but during those few hours, it looks great and stays great.
  • ​Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara  




    ​Ease of Use


    Final Score


    Social Proof

    ​As I said, I bought this mascara because I do enjoy most of the brand’s products. I did plenty of research when looking for the best drugstore mascara products out there and I found that this one had plenty of good reviews, even if there were a few bad ones as well. I think the benefits of the product trump its flaws, but of course, I am subjective.

    [scrapeazon asin="B000W9WZ34" width=“600” height=“600” border="false"]

    ​Alternatives to the Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara

    When you start looking for a product online, you will learn about others, equally interesting. I want to show you a few so you can make an educated choice, especially if you want something for casual every day wear that does not smudge or clump as fast as this one does.

    This is a good product, according to the reviews, and I think I will also try it in the near future.

    Who Should Use this Mascara

    Women who want a long-lasting mascara that does not smudge and lasts for longer hours.

    Maybelline Mascara vs. Hairgenics Mascara Comparison

    • Both are mild for sensitive eyes;
    • Both are good for casual wear;
    • Hairgenics has better black pigmentation;
    • Both help with getting longer lashes, but Hairgenics wins the competition;
    • Hairgenics is much more expensive.

    If you want an alternative to the Maybelline mascara for longer lashes and longer hold, check out the Hairgenics Lavish Lash Mascara as well!

    Both Clinique and Maybelline are known names in the cosmetic and makeup industry. Clinique is perhaps an even stronger brand when it comes to professional products, so the comparison should be interesting.

    Who Should Use this Mascara

    Women who want a great product and are willing to invest in it.

    Maybelline Mascara vs. Clinique Mascara Comparison

    • Clinique is dermatologically tested and cruelty free;
    • Both offer decent eye makeup;
    • Maybelline is much cheaper;
    • Clinique’s black tint is ravishing;
    • Both are suitable for sensitive eyes.

    If you want an alternative to the Maybelline mascara, check out the Clinique Lash Power Mascara as well!

    This is another nice entry on the best drugstore mascara products area – but in the organic department. I think an organic mascara should be on any entry because if you want a mild nourishing mascara for sensitive eyes, you should definitely go organic.

    Who Should Use this Mascara

    Women who want soft, long, lush lashes with the help of an organic product that is great for sensitive eyes and skin. Women who want more than a colored tint on their lashes and look for nourishment, natural ingredients, and a gentle eye treatment.

    Maybelline Mascara vs. EVXO Mascara Comparison

    • Maybelline is not organic;
    • EVXO is vegan, cruelty free, gluten free;
    • EVXO packaging is sustainable and environmentally friendly;
    • Maybelline is much cheaper;
    • Both help with getting long and voluminous lashes.

    If you feel you want to try organic mascara that comes with an environmental friendly approach, is safe for your eyes and skin, and offers good pigmentation and hold, then the EVXO Mineral Mascara may be something you want to buy. If you also want extra nourishment for your lashes, the EVXO is a good start to begin your organic mascara adventure.

    Maybelline Define-A-Lash Lengthening Washable Mascara, Very Black. For Washable Definition and Shape...
    • Use Maybelline Define-A-Lash Lengthening Washable Mascara, Very Black, for...
    • Define-A-Lash Lengthening Washable Mascara gives definition and shape for...
    • To safeguard purity, reserve this mascara for your personal use. Treat the...


    I gave this product a 4.2 rating out of five stars. Maybelline is a strong name in cosmetics and I do own many of their products. What I found disappointing about this one was the brand name correlating with the clumping and flaking. Some may wonder what I expected from a product of this price, but I expected more from Maybelline in general no matter how much more money I had to spend on a mascara.

    The winner here, for me at least, was the black tint and pigmentation and the great coverage it offered. The texture of the product is amazing and the brush can perform miracles. It adheres to the lashes flawlessly and it elongates them, offering them a seductive curve and volume. The main problem is that the product gets clumpy in about 6 or 7 hours and you have to refresh your look.

    Another winning point of this product is the fact that it does not cause discomfort or weird looks if you wear contact lenses. I used my glasses as well sometimes and the mascara did not interfered.

    This mascara is great if you want to look great for at least half the day. If you have time to refresh it, you will look very nice until late evening. I think this product is a good way for teenage girls to learn how and when to use mascara – especially because of the exquisite brush. The incredibly affordable price will make you not regret the purchase.

    There are other best drugstore mascara items on the market. Few beat the price of this one and few are as mild with sensitive eyes and contact lenses as this one is. Many will hold longer without clumping and thus are more appropriate for prolonged day and casual wear. However, if you want a good product with good coverage, then the Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara is a great way to start your mornings!  


    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here