What Is the Best Eyeliner Color for Blue Eyes? (Plus Product Picks We Love)

Today we’re going to look closely at the best eyeliner color for blue eyes, why they work, and which ones are worth your time and money.

You already know that blue eyes are beautiful. Blue eyes are light and bright, and they often have a hint of mystery about them.

They catch the light and keep people’s attention. But if you’ve ever felt stuck wearing the same black eyeliner over and over again, or worried that some colours might clash, you’re not alone.

What’s the good news? There are some great eyeliner colours for blue eyes, and some of the most flattering ones aren’t the first ones that come to mind.

We at Beautifully Alive think that makeup should be fun, expressive, and unique to you. There are no rules when it comes to eyeliner. It’s all about finding what makes your eyes sparkle and your confidence rise when you see yourself in the mirror.

How to Get the Siren Eyes Look (and Our Favourite Products)

Best Lipstick for Your Skin Tone | How to Choose It

Burt’s Bees Makeup Review: Is This A High-Quality Brand?

What Is Airbrush Makeup: Complete Guide

Get a cup of tea, sit back, and let’s talk about eyeliner.

See also:

Why the Colour of Eyeliner Matters for Blue Eyes

Blue eyes are different from other colours because they are lighter and cooler than most other colours.

That means eyeliner can do one of two things:

make them brighter,
make them stand out by using contrast,

or, if you choose the wrong one, make them a little less interesting.

The right colour of eyeliner can make blue eyes look brighter, warmer, or more intense, or all three at once. And even though a lot of people think black eyeliner is always the best choice, it’s not.

The Best Eyeliner Color for Blue Eyes

Let’s begin with the colours that always make blue eyes look brighter, deeper, and more alive.

1. Brown Eyeliner: Soft, flattering, and not well known

If you’ve only ever used black eyeliner, brown might seem like a step down, but for blue eyes, it’s usually a step up.

Why Brown Works
Brown eyeliner gives blue eyes more definition without making them look too harsh. It makes things warmer, which makes the blue stand out even more.

The best brown shades for blue eyes

Brown chocolate
Espresso
Cocoa that is warm

When to Pick Brown

Makeup for every day
School or work
Looks with little or no makeup

Suggested Items

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Demolition: Smooth, long-lasting, and great for everyday use.
Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘N’ Kohl in Barbarella Brown is great for looks that are soft and smudged.
Maybelline Tattoo Studio Gel Pencil in Brown is cheap and has a lot of colour.

2. Copper and bronze: the best colours for your eyes

Blue eyes look great with copper and bronze eyeliners.

What Makes These Colours Stand Out
On the colour wheel, blue and orange are on opposite sides of each other. This means that warm metals like copper and bronze make the most contrast. So what happened? Blue eyes that are brighter and more colourful.

When to Use Copper or Bronze

Nights out
Holidays and special events
Makeup for soft glam

Suggested Items

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Pencil in Bourbon is a cult favourite for a good reason.
Stila Smudge Stick in Bronze: Creamy, easy to blend, and lasts a long time.
Make Up For Ever Artist Colour Pencil in Copper: Bright and well-pigmented.

3. Navy eyeliner is a softer version of black.

Navy is your new best friend if black eyeliner is too harsh but you still want to define your eyes.

Why Navy Works
Navy makes blue eyes look better without making them flat. It has a lot of depth and drama, but it still lets the natural colour of the eyes shine through.

When to Wear Navy

In professional settings
Events in the evening
Everyday looks that are polished

Products We Recommend

Clinique Quickliner in Navy is smooth, easy to use, and good for eyes that are sensitive.
KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner in Navy (when you can find it) makes sharp lines and lasts a long time.
NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick in Blue: cheap and lasts a long time.

4. Bronze-Green and Olive: Beautiful in a Quiet Way

Green tones may not seem like a good match for blue eyes, but they are very pretty.

Why Green Works
Olive and bronze-green colours make blue eyes look less cool and add an earthy contrast that is new and fresh.

When to Pick Green

Looks for the day
Makeup that looks natural or boho
When you want something different but still look good

Suggested Items

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Pencil in Mildew is a beautiful metallic olive colour.
Marc Jacobs Highliner in Earthquake is a deep olive colour that lasts a long time.
NYX Slim Eye Pencil in Moss is cheap and easy to use.

5. Charcoal and Soft Black: The Perfect Smoky Look

Blue eyes can wear black eyeliner, but it needs to be done in a softer way.

Why charcoal is better than jet black
Charcoal gives definition without being too strong, which keeps blue eyes bright instead of dull.

When to Pick Soft Black or Charcoal

Eyes that look smoky
Makeup for the evening
Looks that are lived in and easy to do

Suggested Items

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner in Charcoal is a must-have for makeup artists.
Maybelline Tattoo Studio Gel Pencil in Smoky Black is a great deal.
MAC Fluidline in Graphblack: Smooth and easy to build up.

6. Purple and plum: pretty and romantic

When chosen correctly, purple eyeliner can look great on blue eyes.

Why Purple Works
Plum colours make blue eyes look deeper and stand out without being too bold.

The Best Purple Colours for Blue Eyes

Eggplant
Blackberry
Dark plum

Things We Think You Should Buy

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Pencil in Rockstar is the perfect rich, smoky plum colour.
Purple Sephora Collection Waterproof Eyeliner: creamy and cheap.
The L’Oréal Infallible Pro-Last Pencil in Aubergine is flattering and lasts a long time.

Get Embed Code

7. Gold and Champagne: Brightening Accents

Gold and champagne shades are great for blue eyes, even though they aren’t usually used as full eyeliner.

Why Gold Works
Gold makes blue eyes look warmer and shinier, especially when used sparingly.

Best Uses

Highlights in the inner corner
Accents on the lower lash line
Glam looks for the evening

Suggested Items

Stila Smudge Stick in Gold Rush: Smooth and bright.
NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Frosting: cheap and useful.

How to Pick Eyeliner Based on the Colour of Your Blue Eyes

It’s a good thing that not all blue eyes are the same.

Eyes that are light blue or icy blue
Give it a shot:

Warm browns
Copper
Bronze that is soft

Deep Blue or Sapphire Eyes
Give it a shot:

Navy
Charcoal
Plum

Eyes that are blue-green
Give it a go:

Olive
Bronze-green
Dark teal

The best eyeliner formulas for colour

Some formulas work better than others for showing colour:

Pencil liners are the best for trying out new things.
Gel liners let you control the colour while still being bold.
Liquid liners look best with black, navy, or graphic styles.

If you’re just starting to use colour, a pencil is a good place to start because you can easily smudge and soften it.

Mistakes People with Blue Eyes Make When Wearing Eyeliner

Only using jet black during the day
Not using warm tones at all
Putting a lot of liner on the lower lash line
Not paying attention to undertone differences

Small changes can have a big effect.

A Quick Guide to Eyeliner for Blue Eyes

Brown pencil liner for everyday use
Copper or bronze for soft glam
Navy is a professional polish.
Plum is romantic.
Olive: Earthy
Charcoal: Smoky
Champagne inner corner for brightening

Final Thoughts from Beautifully Alive

Blue eyes are naturally beautiful, but the right eyeliner can make them even more so. The best eyeliner colour for you is the one that makes you feel comfortable in your own skin and confident. It could be soft browns, glowing copper, deep navy, or smoky charcoal.

We at Beautifully Alive think that makeup should be an extension of who you are, not a set of rules you have to follow. Try a different colour. Wipe it out. Try it out on a quiet night and wash it off if you don’t like it.

Your blue eyes already say something. Eyeliner just makes it stand out more.

See also: